- B. Fischer
Minnesota United FCLoan—3 Mar 2026 
Owen Presthus
Columbus CrewLoan—15 Aug 2025- J. Panayotou
New England RevolutionLoan—25 Apr 2025 - S. Anderson
Colorado RapidsFree agent—5 Feb 2025 - Chituru Ethan Odunze
Charlotte——31 Jan 2025 - J. Jiménez
New York City FCFree agent—31 Dec 2024 
P. Walters
FC CincinnatiLoan—8 Mar 2024- M. Ngalina
GöztepeFree—8 Feb 2024 - J. AkpunonuFC CincinnatiLoan—6 Feb 2024
- K. Rad
Sporting Kansas CityFree—9 Mar 2023 - R. Sánchez
Los Angeles GalaxyFree—9 Mar 2023 - Matthew Tyler LampsonColumbus CrewFree—24 Sept 2021
J. HaakNew York City FCLoan—16 Aug 2021- D. Dodson
Orlando City SCLoan—9 Jul 2021 - J. CaldwellNew England RevolutionFree—27 Jan 2021
- C. CropperNew England RevolutionLoan—20 Aug 2019
- Logan GdulaFC CincinnatiLoan—6 Aug 2019
- C. MartinMinnesota United FCLoan—6 Aug 2019
- I. AngkingNew England RevolutionLoan—4 Jul 2019
- Nick FirminoNew England RevolutionLoan—4 Jul 2019
- J. PanayotouNew England RevolutionBack from Loan—1 Dec 2025
- Owen PresthusColumbus CrewReturn from loan—29 Nov 2025
M.DiengMinnesota United FCTransfer—22 Aug 2025- J. PanayotouNew England Revolution——1 Jul 2025
Renan Ribeiro
EstrelaFree agent—5 Feb 2025- D. ToureColorado Rapids——1 Jan 2025
- E. Mushagalusa
Valletta FC——31 Aug 2024 - D. DodsonOrlando City SC——1 Jan 2022
- J. HaakNew York City FC——1 Jan 2022
- Parfait Mandanda
Charleroi——1 Dec 2020 - Nick FirminoNew England Revolution——1 Jan 2020
- Logan GdulaFC Cincinnati——1 Jan 2020
- C. MartinMinnesota United FC——9 Aug 2019
- Logan GdulaFC Cincinnati——26 Jun 2019
- C. MartinMinnesota United FC——7 Jun 2019
- Luis ArgudoColumbus Crew——24 Apr 2019
- J. KempinColumbus Crew——21 Apr 2019